A good software development RFP describes the problem, the users and the outcomes you need, and asks vendors to show how they would deliver. It does not try to specify every screen up front. Include your goals, constraints, budget range, how you will judge progress and who owns the code and data, then ask for short proposals backed by real work samples.
This guide is for owners, operations leaders and IT managers who are about to ask several firms to quote a custom software project. We cover what to include, what to leave out and how to compare the answers you get back.
Why do so many software RFPs get poor answers?
Most weak RFPs fail in one of two ways. Some are a single paragraph, so every vendor guesses at scope and the quotes cannot be compared. Others are a long list of detailed features written before anyone has talked to users. Vendors then price the list, not the problem, and every change after signing becomes a change order.
The fix is to describe what must be true when the work is done and let vendors propose how to get there. U.S. federal digital teams use the same approach. The 18F guide to buying custom software development recommends a statement of objectives, where scope maps to a product vision and performance objectives map to a product backlog.
What should the problem statement include?
Start with the business problem in plain words. Who are the users? What do they do today, and where does it break? What happens to the business if nothing changes?
Then list three to five outcomes you will use to judge success. For example: cut order entry time, remove a duplicate spreadsheet or give customers a self-service status page. Outcomes give vendors something to design toward and give you something to measure later. If you have not settled these yet, start with our list of custom software strategy questions to answer first.
Which constraints and systems should you list?
Vendors price risk. The more they know about your environment, the less padding they add. Include:
- Current systems. Your CRM, ERP, accounting and any tools the new software must read from or write to.
- Data. Where the data lives today, how much there is and how clean it is.
- Security and compliance. Any rules that apply, such as HIPAA, PCI or customer contract terms.
- Hosting. Whether you need a specific cloud, region or on-premises setup.
- Timing. Hard dates, such as a contract renewal or a season, and why they matter.
Should you share your budget in the RFP?
Yes, at least as a range. Without one, quotes can differ by several times because each firm imagines a different product. A range lets vendors propose what fits, and it makes clear early whether a firm is a match.
Before you send the RFP, build your own rough estimate. The 18F guidance suggests preparing an independent cost estimate based on team size and rates, so you can benchmark the proposals that come back. It also advises splitting large systems into smaller projects instead of one giant contract.
What contract terms belong in the RFP?
State the contract shape you expect, so vendors respond on the same basis. The U.S. Digital Services Playbook lists contract checks we find useful for any buyer, including:
- Frequent deliverables, not multi-month milestones.
- Room to change feature priorities as you learn.
- Clear ownership of software and data built for you.
- A warranty period for defects found after launch.
- A transition period and a plan for handing the work to another team.
Fixed price, time and materials or a capped hybrid can all work. Our guide to fixed price vs. time and materials covers the tradeoffs.
What should you ask vendors to send back?
Ask for short, comparable answers. The 18F guide suggests keeping proposals under 10 pages. We would ask for:
- Approach. How they would run discovery, deliver in stages and handle quality, plus the top risks they see and how they would reduce them.
- Team. Who will do the work, their roles and how much of their time is committed.
- Proof. Examples of similar work. For technical buyers, 18F suggests asking for links to two or three code repositories.
- Testing and support. How they test, what happens after launch and what support costs. See what to require for software testing.
- Price. Rates, team size and how the estimate was built, not just a total.
How should you compare the proposals?
Decide your criteria before proposals arrive. 18F recommends weighing approach, team and similar experience more heavily than price, and listing strengths and weaknesses for each proposal instead of scoring by points.
Then talk to the people who would actually work on your project. A short interview tells you more than a polished slide deck. Ask how they would handle a real change, such as a new integration halfway through. Check references from clients with projects of similar size.
What are the most common RFP mistakes?
- Copying a feature list from a competitor's product.
- Leaving out integrations and data migration, which are often the hardest parts.
- Choosing on price alone, then paying for change orders.
- Forgetting to state who owns the code, data and hosting accounts.
- Giving vendors too little time to ask questions.
Frequently asked questions
It is a request for proposal that describes a software project and asks development firms to propose an approach, team, timeline and price so you can compare them on the same basis.
Long enough to explain the problem, users, outcomes, systems, constraints, budget range and contract terms. For most business projects that fits in a few pages plus attachments.
Three to five qualified firms is usually enough to compare approaches and prices without overwhelming your team during evaluation.
Include outcomes, key workflows and must-have constraints. Leave detailed screen-level requirements for a paid discovery phase, where they can be tested with real users.
Planning a custom software RFP?
We can help you scope the problem, set outcomes and a realistic budget range, or respond with a clear, staged proposal of our own.
Explore custom development services
